He's there. But she's not.

The Moment

For the better part of a century, the pew was a woman's domain.

American churches were sustained, week after week, by women who showed up when men didn't. They organized, volunteered, prayed, taught, and passed the faith to the next generation while their husbands stayed home. The gender gap in church attendance was so consistent and so long-standing that researchers treated it as a sociological constant.

New data from Barna Group, tracking more than 130,000 adults over 25 years, suggests 2025 may represent a turning point. Young men — Gen Z and Millennials — are now attending church at roughly the same rate as young women. In some measures, men are outpacing women for the first time in recorded survey history. At the same time, young women are leaving in numbers that concern researchers and church leaders alike.

The Story

Barna's State of the Church data shows that since 2019, the proportion of Gen Z men who say they have made a personal commitment to follow Jesus has risen by 15 percent. Millennial men are up 19 percent over the same period. Married fathers are now the most consistent churchgoers of any parental group.

The data on women runs in the opposite direction. Young women — particularly Gen Z — are leaving institutional church at accelerating rates. Barna's president David Kinnaman has pointed to repeated examples of moral failure and leadership hypocrisy in church institutions as a driving factor. Single mothers are now the least likely demographic to attend church weekly.

The UK data is even sharper. The Bible Society's Quiet Revival report found monthly church attendance among 18-to-24-year-olds in England and Wales quadrupled between 2018 and 2024 — from 4 percent to 16 percent. Young men drove most of that increase, rising from 4 percent to 21 percent in the same period.

The headline version of this story is encouraging: men are coming back. The full version is more complex: the church appears to be gaining one demographic while losing another.

What It Reveals

The question worth sitting with is not simply why young men are returning. It is what they are returning to — and what young women are walking away from.

Researchers have noted that young men are drawn to churches offering substance: theological depth, clear moral frameworks, authentic community, and a defined sense of purpose and calling. Churches that speak clearly to what it means to be a man — that offer a vision of masculinity rooted in responsibility, service, and conviction rather than performance — are finding audiences they haven't had in decades.

The question for women runs in two directions simultaneously. Some of the departure is driven by legitimate grievance. Investigations into multiple major Protestant institutions — including a landmark 2022 independent review of the Southern Baptist Convention — documented patterns of dismissing and discouraging women who reported abuse, protecting institutions over survivors, and treating women's concerns as threats rather than responsibilities. These are not isolated failures. They are the kind of institutional betrayal that erodes trust over years and generations.

But a second force is operating at the same time. Research consistently shows that young women are the demographic most heavily shaped by progressive social media environments — platforms where traditional faith is framed not as truth but as a threat to women's autonomy and dignity. Identity is being formed online before it is formed anywhere else. By the time a young woman considers whether the church has anything to offer her, the cultural answer has often already been supplied.

Separating those two threads matters — because they require entirely different responses. One is a failure the church must own and correct. The other is a formation battle the church must show up to fight.

A church that recovers men without recovering women has not recovered. It has traded one imbalance for another.

The Frame

The Christian vision of the church was never a men's club. It was never a women's auxiliary either. The New Testament picture is a community of men and women, each bearing the image of God, each carrying distinct callings, each essential to the body's full function.

The man who protects, provides, and presides. The woman who nurtures, anchors, and sustains. Both are diminished when the other is absent. A church full of men without women loses its warmth and its roots. A church full of women without men loses its spine. The body needs both to function as it was designed.

The data showing men returning is good news. The data showing women leaving is a serious challenge — not to be explained away by cultural politics, but to be taken seriously by every church that wants to be what the New Testament describes.

What It Asks

The trend is an invitation — to every church, every pastor, every formed believer who cares about what the local congregation becomes.

For the men returning: the question is not whether you showed up. It is what you will build now that you are there. The church does not need men in the pews. It needs men who understand that the seat they've taken carries responsibility — to lead, to serve, to create a community where the women in their lives would also want to be.

For the women considering leaving: the grievances are real and the failures of institutional church are documented. But the answer to a broken institution is rarely to abandon it. It is to stay, to hold it accountable, and to build something better from the inside.

The church has always been most itself when it could not be reduced to a single demographic. The moment the data is describing is not a victory. It is a starting line.

Learn more about The Guardians' Cross → theguardianscross.org